Monday, July 8, 2013

Chapters 10-11

NOTE: Page numbers refer to the Barnes & Noble Classics paperback edition.

Background Information/Vocabulary:

Here's what each girl grew in her garden.  Sources for each photo are linked to the name of each item










My Noticings:
  •  This book never tires of giving us symbolic depictions of the four sisters!  In this chapter, we get their gardens, their Dickensian alter-egos, and their contributions to the paper.  I hadn't noticed before how repetitive this can get (sort of like having the infamous first chapter of a Baby-Sitters Club novel recur every twenty pages or so) but I will never cease to find it charming. 
  • Pip (named, I guess, for Dickens's Pip?) strikes me as an uncharacteristically dark bit of this story!  I understand the idea behind this chapter showing how out-of-sorts people can get when they haven't anything to occupy their time, but Beth starving one of her pets to death seems a bit much.  (I suppose this is mitigated by the fact that we've never heard of Pip before--better this newly discovered bird than one of the beloved kittens!)

Final Thoughts: 

In this section, we get a longer glimpse of the Marches' home life; the Pickwick Society that keeps the girls occupied during their free time and the chores that they normally do to keep the household running (but skip for a week, to tragic results.)   As usual, we see a bit of each girl, most notably another of Jo's early attempts at writing (quite over-the-top and melodramatic) and Meg's shortcomings as a housekeeper (spoiling her clothes and the breakfast). 

 Question for readers:

If you had to use some of the symbols applied to the March sisters to describe yourself, what would you use?  So far we've seen:

  • The small item each girl wants to buy herself at Christmas
  • The chore each girl takes on to get ready for Marmee's homecoming (and then how each girl helps get ready for dinner when Marmee arrives)
  • The gift each girl gives Marmee
  • The role(s) each girl plays in the theatrical performance
  • Each girl's favorite part of playing Pilgrim's Progress
  • The color of the books Marmee gives to each girl
  • The gift each girl sends to Laurie when he's sick
  • The plants growing in each girl's garden
  • The Dickens character each girl pretends to be

No comments:

Post a Comment